Economy
Please note that yesterday we published Special Report titled Do Not Overlook China’s Innovation Drive. Please click on it to access it. Today, we publish analysis on Brazil and Ukraine. Chart I-1Brazilian Share Prices And Commodity Prices Move In Tandem A FOMO (fear-of-missing-out) mania has pushed equity prices higher around the world. Brazilian stocks, currency and credit markets, likewise, have been staging a rebound. There is evidence that in Brazil equity purchases by local investors have been driving up share prices.1 The absolute performance of Brazilian share prices and the exchange rate trend will likely depend on commodities prices and a global rally in risk assets (Chart I-1). In relative terms, Brazilian financial markets will underperform their EM counterparts because of the following: Brazil is on track for its worst economic contraction in the past century following the deep recession of 2014-2016 (Chart I-2). This is the first nominal GDP contraction in Brazil. Growth was feeble even before the pandemic struck, but the COVID-19 lockdowns were the last nail in the coffin for the economy. Given that Brazil has not been able to control the spread of the virus – having hit another high in daily new infections last Friday – major cities will be forced to maintain social distancing measures for longer, delaying a recovery in consumer and business confidence. Chart I-2The Level Of Economic Activity In Real And Nominal Terms Table I-1Brazil's Fiscal Package Is The Largest In The Region While Brazil has deployed the largest COVID-19 fiscal package in the region (Table I-1), its economic recovery will lag behind the majority of EM and DM countries. State-sponsored loans have not been reaching small and micro businesses, which employ over half of the working force. Moreover, informal workers amount to about 20% of the country’s total population, and they also have not been receiving any economic benefits other than a $120 US dollar monthly stipend. Household income growth was subdued during the 2017-2019 recovery. To support their living standards, families were aggressively borrowing before the pandemic (Chart I-3, top panel). Now, with their income contracting and household debt servicing costs above 20% of disposable income, consumer loan defaults will mushroom (Chart I-3, bottom panel). Chart I-4 shows that non-performing loans (NPL) for households are rising as a share of total consumer loans. Chart I-3Household Income, Credit And Debt Service Chart I-4Mushrooming Consumer Delinquencies The private banks’ NPL provisions are set to surge due to rising defaults. Consumer loans make up 53% of private banks’ non-earmarked (non state-directed) lending. Chart I-5 shows that bank share prices are highly correlated with the annual change in provisions (shown inverted). Hence, the further rise in provisions will continue undermining bank share prices. We published a Special Report on Brazilian banks on March 31 and their outlook remains dismal. Besides, facing high credit risks, private banks have tightened credit standards and loan origination is plummeting, further hurting the economy. The sheer size of the fiscal stimulus and the historic nominal GDP contraction will push the gross public debt-to-GDP ratio well above 100% by end-2020. As discussed in our previous reports,2 and provided local currency interest rates remain above nominal GDP growth, public debt is on an unsustainable trajectory (Chart I-6). Chart I-5Do Not Chase Brazilian Bank Stocks Chart I-6Government Bond Yields Are Well Above Nominal GDP Growth Chart I-7The Social Security Deficit Is Widening The only way to stabilize the public debt-to-GDP ratio in Brazil is via the central bank conducting substantial quantitative easing, i.e. monetary authorities purchasing local government bonds. This will push local bond yields much lower and over time boost nominal GDP growth. With interest rate on government debt below nominal GDP growth over several years, the condition of public debt sustainability will be achieved. However, this amounts to monetization of public debt and, if carried on a large scale, it will suffocate the exchange rate – the currency would depreciate a lot. Furthermore, the projected BRL 800 billion (11% of GDP) in savings from the infamous pension reform will be impossible to achieve. Chart I-7 shows that the social security deficit has widened since March due to the shortfall in revenues. Given social security revenues are derived from taxes on workers and businesses, this deficit will continue to increase as employment and wages collapse while pension payouts remain fixed. Finally, the political situation is in disarray and a presidential impeachment might be inevitable. President Bolsonaro has become even more radical and is in conflict with various branches of power. Meanwhile, corruption and electoral fraud investigations against him and his allies continue to develop. The key risk to our negative view is as follows: One could argue that investors have lost faith in the Bolsonaro administration and are actually looking forward to his removal from office. Hence, the escalating political crisis culminating in Bolsonaro’s impeachment would be bullish for financial markets. This is a valid perspective given Vice-president Mourão – who has the backing of the army and adheres to a more centrist view on a wide range of issues - would assume the presidency in the case of impeachment. He would maintain orthodox economic policies and cooperate with Congress. This kind of thinking from investors might be taking its cues from the political dynamics and market actions in early 2016, when Brazilian markets bottomed seven months before then President Dilma Rousseff was impeached. Brazil is on track for its worst economic contraction in the past century following the deep recession of 2014-2016. In addition, the long-term political outlook for Brazil might be turning positive. The quite popular ex-Justice Minister Sergio Moro hinted last week that he could run in the 2022 presidential race. While he did not explicitly announce his candidacy, he stated that he wants to “participate” in the public debate by presenting a pro-market and anti-corruption alternative to Bolsonaro. If Moro runs, he will likely win given his enormous popularity. His victory will be accordingly cheered by international and domestic investors as he would run on a platform of structural reforms. Chart I-8The Brazilian Real Is Only Modestly Cheap Nevertheless, in the near term Bolsonaro will try to maintain his grip on power as long as he can. Foreseeing the risk of impeachment, he has strengthened his ties with the big coalition of small centrist parties in Congress. For now, it is not clear if Congress will vote for his removal. Importantly, the more radical and autocratic Bolsonaro becomes in a bid to save his presidency, the higher the odds of Economy Minister Paulo Guedes resigning. This was the case with the Ministers of Health and Justice and the Secretary of the Treasury. The latter was a key figure in drafting economic reforms. If Guedes resigns, it will send shockwaves throughout the nation’s financial markets. Bottom Line: Continue underweighting Brazilian equities and fixed income within their respective EM universes. We took profits on our short BRL/long USD position on June 4th due to tactical considerations. Investors should consider shorting the BRL again. The BRL is somewhat but not very cheap (Chart I-8). Juan Egaña Research Associate juane@bcaresearch.com Arthur Budaghyan Chief Emerging Markets Strategist arthurb@bcaresearch.com Ukraine: An Opportunity In Bonds Is Still Present Investors should stay long local currency government bonds and continue overweighting the nation’s sovereign credit within the EM sovereign credit universe. Ukraine is pursuing prudent fiscal policy under the auspices of the IMF. With the government refraining from announcing a large-scale fiscal spending package amid the COVID-19 outbreak, its fiscal overall and primary deficits will widen to 8% and 4% of GDP, respectively. In particular, the increase in healthcare and social spending will be partially offset by both a reduction in discretionary spending and a cap on public wages. Such a conservative policy approach is negative for growth but will result in lower inflation and a stable exchange rate. Critically, a prudent fiscal policy will allow the central bank to cut interest rates. Both headline and core consumer price inflation are well below the lower end of the central bank’s target band (Chart II-1). Nominal wage growth is heading toward zero and will probably deflate by the end of this year (Chart II-2). Falling domestic demand will ensure that any rise in inflation due to currency depreciation will be modest. Chart II-1Inflation Is Undershooting Chart II-2Wage Growth Is Subdued! As a result of considerable disinflation, real interest rates are still very high. Elevated real rates warrant large interest rate cuts by the central bank. Deflated by core consumer inflation, the real policy rate is 8% and the real lending rate is 12% for companies and over 30% for consumer credit (Chart II-3). A conservative policy approach is negative for growth but will result in lower inflation and a stable exchange rate. High real rates will entice foreign portfolio capital. Chart II-4 demonstrates that foreign investors have reduced their holdings of local bonds from $5.2 billion at the end of 2019 to $3.75 billion currently. Given the very low real rates worldwide, Ukraine is one of few markets offering high real rates with decent macro policies, at least in the medium term. Chart II-3Elevated Real Rates Warrant More Rate Cuts By CB Chart II-4Foreign Inflows Could Resume With regard to the balance of payments, the recently announced $5 billion IMF loan should help ease short-term funding for the country. The 18-month arrangement will provide the immediate disbursement of $2.1 billion with a second disbursement of $0.7 billion expected by the end of September after the IMF program review. Importantly, plummeting imports and relatively resilient exports will narrow the current account deficit (Chart II-5). Exports should remain supported by food exports, which represents close to 40% of overall exports. Besides, the central bank also carries $25 billion in foreign exchange reserves, which compares with $18 billion in foreign funding requirements for 2020 (Chart II-6). So far, the central bank has refrained from selling foreign exchange reserves but might do so if the currency depreciates significantly. Chart II-5Current Account Will Balance Soon Chart II-6Foreign Funding Requirements Are Covered By FX Reserves Bottom Line: We continue to recommend holding 5-year local currency government bonds currently yielding 11%. Even though moderate currency depreciation cannot be ruled out, on a total return basis domestic bonds will deliver decent returns to foreign investors in the next 6-12 months. EM fixed income investors should continue overweighting domestic bonds and sovereign US dollar credit within respective EM portfolios. Andrija Vesic Associate Editor andrijav@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1 Investors ignore triple crisis and bet on equities 2 Please see Emerging Markets Strategy Countries In-Depth "Brazil: Deflationary Pressures Warrant A Weaker BRL," dated November 28, 2019 available at ems.bcaresearch.com Please see Emerging Markets Strategy Countries In-Depth "Brazil: Just Above "Stall Speed"," dated September 27, 2019 available at ems.bcaresearch.com Equities Recommendations Currencies, Credit And Fixed-Income Recommendations
Highlights The economic performance of Sweden, which did not have a lockdown, has been almost as bad as Denmark, which did have a lockdown. This proves that the current recession is not ‘man-made’, it is ‘pandemic-made’. While the pandemic remains in play, investors should maintain a defensive bias to their portfolios: favouring US T-bonds in bond portfolios, and technology and healthcare in equity portfolios. The technology sector has become defensive, largely because it has flipped from hardware dominance to software dominance. A new recommendation is to overweight technology-heavy Netherlands. Fractal trade: short AUD/CHF. Feature Chart I-IASweden: Avoiding A Lockdown Did Not Prevent A Slump In Consumption... Chart I-1B...But Led To Many More ##br##Infections Sweden and Denmark are neighbours. They speak near-identical languages and share a broadly similar culture and demographic. Yet the two countries have followed completely different strategies to halt the coronavirus pandemic. Sweden chose not to impose a lockdown. Instead, it opted for a ‘trust based’ approach, relying on its citizens to act sensibly and appropriately. Whereas Denmark imposed one of Europe’s earliest and most draconian lockdowns. The contrasting approaches of Sweden and neighbouring Denmark provide us with the closest thing to a controlled experiment on pandemic strategies. The Recession Is Not ‘Man-Made’, It Is ‘Pandemic-Made’ The surprising thing is that the economic performance of Sweden, which did not have a lockdown, has been almost as bad as Denmark, which did. This year, the unemployment rates in both economies have surged by 2 percentage points (albeit the latest data is for May in Sweden and April in Denmark). Furthermore, high-frequency measures of consumption show that Sweden suffered almost as severe a contraction as Denmark (Chart of the Week and Chart I-2). Chart I-2Unemployment Has Surged In Both No-Lockdown Sweden And Lockdown Denmark This surprising result challenges the popular view that this global recession is man-made. This view argues that without the government-imposed lockdowns, the global economy would not have entered a tailspin. But if this view is right, then why did consumption crash in Sweden? The simple answer is that in a pandemic, most people will change their behaviour to avoid catching the virus. The cautious behaviour is voluntary, irrespective of whether there is no lockdown, as in Sweden, or there is a lockdown, as in Denmark. People will shun public transport, shopping, and other crowded places, and even think twice about letting their children go to school. In a pandemic, the majority of people will change their behaviour even without a lockdown. But if the cautious behaviour is voluntary, then why impose a lockdown? The answer is that without a lockdown, the majority will behave sensibly to avoid catching the virus, but a minority will take a ‘devil may care’ attitude. In the pandemic, this is critical because less than 10 percent of infected people are responsible for creating 90 percent of all coronavirus infections. If this tiny minority of so-called ‘super-spreaders’ is left unchecked, then the pandemic will let rip. All of which brings us back to Sweden versus Denmark. As a result of not imposing a mandatory lockdown to rein in its super-spreaders, Sweden now has one of the world’s worst coronavirus infection and mortality rates, four times higher than Denmark (Chart I-3, Chart I-4, Chart I-5). Chart I-3No-Lockdown Sweden Has Suffered Many More Deaths Than Lockdown Denmark Chart I-4Avoiding A Lockdown Meant More Infections… Chart I-5…And More ##br##Deaths Put simply, containing the pandemic depends on reining in a minority of super-spreaders. Which explains why no-lockdown Sweden suffered a much worse outbreak of the disease than lockdown Denmark. In contrast, the economy depends on the behaviour of the majority. In a pandemic the majority will voluntarily exercise caution. Which explains why no-lockdown Sweden and lockdown Denmark suffered similar contractions in consumption. Looking ahead, will the widespread adoption of face masks and plexiglass screens change the public’s cautious behaviour? To a certain extent, yes – it will permit essential activities and let people take calculated risks. That said, if you are forced to wear a mask on public transport and in the shops, and you have to spread out in restaurants while being served by a masked waiter, then – rightly or wrongly – you are getting a strong signal: the danger is still out there. Meaning that many people will continue to shun discretionary activities and spending. The upshot is that while the pandemic remains in play, investors should maintain a defensive bias to their portfolios. Explaining Why Technology Is Now Defensive A defensive bias to your portfolio now requires an exposure to technology – because in 2020 the tech sector is behaving like a classic defensive. Its relative performance is correlating positively with the bond price, like other classic defensive sectors such as healthcare (Chart I-6 and Chart I-7). Chart I-6In 2020, Tech Is Behaving Like A Defensive... Chart I-7...Like Healthcare The behaviour of the technology sector in the current recession contrasts with its performance in the global financial crisis of 2008. Back then, it behaved like a classic cyclical – its relative performance correlated negatively with the bond price (Chart I-8). Begging the question: why has the tech sector’s behaviour flipped from cyclical to defensive? Chart I-8In 2008, Tech Behaved Like A Cyclical The main reason is that the tech sector’s composition has flipped from hardware dominance to software dominance. In 2008, the sector market cap had a 65:35 tilt to technology hardware. But today, it is the mirror-image: a 65:35 tilt to computer and software services (Chart I-9). Chart I-9Tech Is More Defensive Now Because It Is Dominated By Software Computer and software services have many defensive characteristics suited to the current environment: For many companies, enterprise software is now business critical. It is a must-have rather than a like-to-have. Computer and software services use a subscription-based revenue model, minimising the dependency on discretionary spending. Computer and software services are helping firms to cut costs through automation and back-office efficiencies as well as facilitating the boom in ‘working from home’. The sector is cash rich. Despite these defensive characteristics, there remains a lingering worry: is the tech sector overvalued? The Rally In Growth Defensives Is Not A Mania Some people fear that the recent run-up in stock markets does not make sense, other than as a ‘Robin Hood’ day-trader fuelled mania. After all, the pandemic is still very much in play, and so are other geopolitical risks, so how can some stock prices be near all-time highs? Yet the recent run-up in growth defensives such as tech and healthcare does make sense. Their valuations have moved in near-perfect lockstep with the bond yield, implying that the rally is based on fundamentals (Chart I-10). Chart I-10Tech And Healthcare Valuations Are Tracking The Bond Yield Simply put, if the 10-year T-bond is going to deliver a pitiful 0.7 percent a year over the next decade, then the prospective return from growth defensives must also compress. It would be absurd to expect these stocks to be priced for high single digit returns. Since late 2018, the decline in growth defensives’ forward earnings yield has broadly tracked the 250bps decline in the 10-year T-bond yield. Given that the forward earnings yield correlates well with the 10-year prospective return, the depressed bond yield is depressing the prospective return from growth defensives – as it should. Tech and healthcare valuations have moved in near-perfect lockstep with the bond yield. But with the pandemic and geopolitical risks menacing in the background, shouldn’t the gap between the prospective return on stocks and bonds – the equity risk premium – be larger? This is open to debate. When bond yields approach the lower bound, the appeal of owning bonds also diminishes because bond prices have limited upside. Nevertheless, the gap between the tech and healthcare forward earnings yield and the bond yield has gone up this year and is much larger than in 2018 (Chart I-11). This suggests that valuations are taking some account of the pandemic and other risks. Moreover, in a longer-term perspective the current gap between the tech and healthcare forward earnings yield and the bond yield, at +4 percent, hardly indicates a mania. In the true mania of 2000, the gap stood at -4 percent! (Chart I-12) Chart I-11The Equity Risk Premium Has Risen In 2020 Chart I-12Tech And Health Care Valuations Are Not In A Mania In summary, until the pandemic is conquered, investors should maintain a defensive bias to their portfolios. Bond investors should overweight US T-bonds versus core European bonds. Equity investors should overweight the growth defensives, technology and healthcare, which implies overweighting the technology-heavy US versus Europe. A new recommendation is to overweight technology-heavy Netherlands. Stay overweight healthcare-heavy Switzerland, and bank-light France and Germany (albeit expect a technical 5 percent underperformance of Germany versus the UK in the coming weeks). And stay underweight bank-heavy Austria. Fractal Trading System* The AUD is technically overbought and vulnerable to a tactical reversal. Accordingly, this week’s recommended trade is short AUD/CHF, with a profit target and symmetrical stop-loss set at 4.2 percent. The rolling 1-year win ratio now stands at 63 percent. Chart I-13AUD/CHF When the fractal dimension approaches the lower limit after an investment has been in an established trend it is a potential trigger for a liquidity-triggered trend reversal. Therefore, open a countertrend position. The profit target is a one-third reversal of the preceding 13-week move. Apply a symmetrical stop-loss. Close the position at the profit target or stop-loss. Otherwise close the position after 13 weeks. * For more details please see the European Investment Strategy Special Report “Fractals, Liquidity & A Trading Model,” dated December 11, 2014, available at eis.bcaresearch.com. Dhaval Joshi Chief European Investment Strategist dhaval@bcaresearch.com Fractal Trading System Cyclical Recommendations Structural Recommendations Closed Fractal Trades Trades Closed Trades Asset Performance Currency & Bond Equity Sector Country Equity Indicators Bond Yields Chart II-1Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-2Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-3Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Chart II-4Indicators To Watch - Bond Yields Interest Rate Chart II-5Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-6Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-7Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations Chart II-8Indicators To Watch - Interest Rate Expectations
The European economy has room to catch up to the US. The gap between the euro area and the US economic surprise index lingers near all-time lows. While the European surprise index is recovering, it lags well behind the US indicator, which stands at a record…
The flash PMIs for June confirm the notion that the global economy is experiencing a quick rebound as activity resumes after prolonged lockdowns. In the euro area, the Manufacturing PMI jumped from 39.4 in May to 46.9. The Services PMI surged from 30.5 to…
Highlights Global Inflation: The worst of the 2020 collapse in global inflation is over; economic growth is starting to rebound, monetary and fiscal policies are highly stimulative, commodity prices are rising and the US dollar is losing some steam. This boosts the investment case for developed market inflation-linked bonds, which appear cheap on our models on a breakeven basis versus nominal government debt. Inflation-Linked Bonds: Starting this week, we are permanently adding inflation-linked bonds as a “discretionary” allocation option in our model bond portfolio framework. We begin with allocations to linkers in the US, Italy and Canada. Tactical Overlay 2.0: We are introducing our revamped Tactical Trade Overlay, using specific securities to implement shorter-term trade ideas in a practical fashion. This week, we begin by initiating inflation-linked bond breakeven trades in the US, Italy and Canada. Feature Chart of the WeekThe Early Days Of An Inflation Expectations Revival With global growth now showing signs of rebounding from the COVID-19 recession as lockdown restrictions ease, inflation expectations in the major developed economies have started to drift upward. Higher inflation breakevens have helped stabilized nominal government bond yields in the majority of countries, even with the latest reads on realized inflation still showing few signs of life (Chart of the Week). In our view, it is still far too soon for bond investors to shift to a below-benchmark stance on overall duration exposure. The threat of a new set of COVID-19 lockdowns is growing, given surging numbers of new infections across much of the southern US and in major emerging economies like Brazil and India. The social and political instability in the US, with elections less than five months away, raises the risk of a renewed flare-up of negative headline risk that can upset overheated equity and credit markets. Amidst all that uncertainty, policymakers worldwide will continue to use aggressive monetary and fiscal stimulus to fight off the risk of an extended recession. That means there is little risk of a big surge in global bond yields from a hawkish repricing of central bank policy expectations over at least the next 6-12 months. At the same time, the extraordinarily loose policy settings, combined with the continued rebound in global commodity prices (most notably, oil), should allow inflation expectations to continue drifting higher. While this will likely also push nominal bond yields higher as well, positioning for wider inflation breakevens remains the “cleaner” way to position for the initial impact of policy reflation. In a report published back on April 28, we introduced a series of valuation models for inflation-linked bonds in the developed economies.1 These models showed that the historic collapse in global oil prices earlier this year, combined with the deflationary impulse from the deep global COVID-19 recession, pushed breakeven inflation rates to levels well below fair value in most countries. Positioning for wider inflation breakevens remains the “cleaner” way to position for the initial impact of policy reflation. This week, we take the output from our inflation breakeven models to determine specific inflation-linked trade recommendations over both strategic (6-12 months) and tactical (0-6 months) time horizons. For the former, we are adding inflation-linked bonds as an allocation option for all countries in our model bond portfolio. For the latter, we are reviving our Tactical Trade Overlay by introducing some specific trade recommendations using actual inflation-linked bonds in the US, Europe and Canada. Why Global Inflation Expectations Have Bottomed The recent pickup in global market-based inflation expectations has occurred even as actual realized headline inflation rates have fallen dangerously close to 0% in the US, euro area and the UK (Chart 2). Canada is now in outright deflation, with the year-over-year rate of headline CPI inflation falling to -0.4% in May. The decline is not fully attributable to the earlier collapse in oil prices, as core inflation rates have also fallen across the developed world. Chart 2A Threat Of Realized Deflation Despite the plunge in realized inflation, inflation expectations have moved higher for both market-based indicators like inflation breakevens and survey-based measures as well. Chart 3Inflation Expectations Improving Everywhere …. Chart 4… Even Within Europe The German ZEW economic research institute - well known for their surveys of economic forecasters for Germany and the major developed countries - also produces inflation expectations surveys for the same countries. In Charts 3 & 4, we show those ZEW inflation expectations measures alongside the breakeven inflation rates for 10-year government bonds in the US, UK, Japan and the euro area including country-level data for Germany, France and Italy. It is clear that the upturn in breakevens has also occurred as a growing number of economic forecasters have started to anticipate a move higher in both economic growth and inflation over the next year. With recent economic data surprising to the upside in the US, China and in much of Europe, a more optimistic view on global growth is a logical reason helping explain why inflation expectations have been drifting higher. Even more so has been a shift in the deflationary momentum stemming from a rising US dollar and falling commodity prices – trends that are in the process of reversing. Perhaps the strongest deflationary force over the past couple of years has been the persistent strength of the US dollar. World export prices have been contracting on a year-over-year basis since December 2018, which has coincided with a similar period of positive annual growth in the trade-weighted US dollar since June 2018 (Chart 5). While the dollar is still at elevated levels, its momentum has started to roll over (middle panel), suggesting less deflationary pressure from the currency. The same can be said for commodity prices, which reflect both the global demand story and the trend in the US dollar as well, given that important industrial commodities like oil and copper are priced in US dollars. With the prices of those commodities off their lows, the annual growth rates of the CRB Energy and Metals indices have bottomed out, implying less global deflationary pressure from commodities (bottom panel). A reflationary boost to the global economy – and to inflation expectations – from a softer dollar is likely over the next 6-12 months. Looking ahead, the US dollar is likely to continue losing strength for two reasons: less-supportive interest rate differentials and improving global growth (Chart 6). The Fed’s aggressive interest rate cuts over the past year have eliminated much of the attractive carry that helped fuel the dollar’s rise over the past few years. At the same time, the US dollar remains an “anti-growth” currency that tends to weaken during periods of improving global growth, and vice versa. Chart 5Easing Of Disinflationary Pressures From The USD & Commodities Chart 6A Softer USD Will Help Lift Global Inflation Expectations With global growth starting to emerge from the COVID-19 recession, the US dollar is now more exposed to less attractive interest rate differentials. This suggests that a reflationary boost to the global economy – and to inflation expectations – from a softer dollar is likely over the next 6-12 months. Chart 7Rising Oil Prices Will Help Lift Global Inflation Expectations The same can be said for commodity prices like oil, which have considerable upside as global growth improves. Our colleagues at BCA Research Commodity & Energy Strategy are quite bullish on the outlook for oil over the next 12-18 months, given the improved demand/supply balance and aggressive global monetary and fiscal stimulus. Their expect the Brent benchmark to rise to $46/bbl by the end of 2020 and $73/bbl by the end of 2021 – levels that would push inflation expectations in the US and other major developed markets higher given the usual strong correlation between oil and breakevens (Chart 7).2 Summing it all up, the trends that have helped stabilize and lift global inflation expectations look set to continue over the next 6-12 months. Bottom Line: The worst of the 2020 collapse in global inflation is over; economic growth is starting to rebound, monetary and fiscal policies are highly stimulative, commodity prices are rising and the US dollar is losing some steam. This boosts the investment case for developed market inflation-linked bonds, which appear cheap on our models on a breakeven basis versus nominal government debt. Adding Inflation-Linked Bonds To Our Model Bond Portfolio Our model bond portfolio framework is how we translate our main global fixed income strategic themes into actual investment recommendations. We apply specific weightings to government bond and spread product allocations within a fully invested hypothetical portfolio with a custom benchmark index (which is essentially the Bloomberg Barclays Global Aggregate with additional allocations to high-yield and emerging market corporates). We had not included inflation-linked bonds in the model portfolio, as we have always maintained a focus on the larger and more liquid parts of the developed market fixed income universe. We chose to express views on inflation expectations through duration or yield curve positioning, under the assumption that wider breakevens correlate to higher bond yields and/or steeper yield curves. Chart 8Global Inflation Breakevens Are Too Low We now are of the view that inflation-linked bonds should be included in our model portfolio investment universe, but on an “opportunistic” basis. In other words, we are not adding linkers to the custom benchmark index. Instead, we will be using potential allocations to inflation-linked bonds as another way to play for periods of rising inflation expectations beyond recommended duration and curve tilts in the model portfolio – particularly now that we have valuation models for inflation breakevens in almost all countries in the portfolio (the US, UK, Japan, Germany, Italy, France, Canada and Australia). Based on the output of our fundamental fair value framework for 10-year inflation breakevens, inflation protection looks “cheap” in all countries where we have valuation models except the UK (Chart 8). Charts with the details of each country’s 10-year inflation breakeven model can be found in the Appendix on pages 11-14. The inputs to the model are the same for each country: a) the 5-year moving average of headline CPI, representing the medium-term trend that anchors inflation expectations; and b) the annual percentage change in the Brent oil price in local currency terms, which creates deviations from the trend to account for moves in oil and currencies. For all countries excluding the UK, breakevens are below fair value because of the collapse in oil prices earlier this year. Inflation protection looks “cheap” in all countries where we have valuation models except the UK. The UK is the one market that does not appear cheap in our framework, with breakevens very close to both fair value and the medium-term trend in realized inflation. Those relatively high breakevens are also a reflection of the very low real bond yields for UK index-linked Gilts. Chart 9Linkers Offer Better Value In The US & Euro Area Than The UK For the past several years, UK real yields have traded well below measures of equilibrium real interest rates like the New York Fed’s estimates of “r-star”. This differs from real yields for US TIPS or French OATis, which trade roughly in line with the r-star estimates for the US and euro area (Chart 9). We suspect that is because of the chronic demand/supply mismatch for UK inflation-linked bonds, which are always in high demand from UK pension funds who need real assets for asset/liability management and regulatory purposes. So based on the output from the fair value models, inflation-linked bonds look most attractive on a breakeven basis in Italy, Canada, the US, Japan, Germany and France. From this list, we are choosing to add recommended positions in the US, Italy and Canada only. For Germany and France, we are already very underweight both countries in the model portfolio, so it is difficult to make a meaningful switch out of nominal bonds into linkers. For Japan, the Bank of Japan’s Yield Curve Control policy, which caps the level of 10-year bond yields near 0%, makes us reluctant to recommend any breakeven widening positions. The changes to the model bond portfolio can be found in the tables on pages 15-16. Bottom Line: Starting this week, we are permanently adding inflation-linked bonds as a “discretionary” allocation option in our model bond portfolio framework. We begin with allocations to linkers in the US, Italy and Canada. Tactical Trade Overlay 2.0, Starting With Inflation-Linked Bonds This week, we are introducing a remodeled version of our Tactical Trade Overlay, which we put on hiatus a few months ago because of “mission creep”. Many of our recommendations were being held too long to be truly considered tactical, or short-term, in nature, thus defying the original purpose of the Overlay. This week, we are introducing a remodeled version of our Tactical Trade Overlay, which we put on hiatus a few months ago because of “mission creep”. All trades in the new Overlay will have a shorter term investment horizon of six months or less. All recommended trades will be implemented with specific securities, rather than just using generic Bloomberg tickers or bond indices. This will allow for a more transparent process where clients can “follow along” with the performance of our trades. Chart 10Inflation-Linked Bonds Have A Duration To Real Yields, Unlike Nominals To begin, we are putting three inflation-linked bond trades into our new Tactical Trade Overlay, positioning for wider 10-year breakevens in the US, Italy and Canada. All trades will be implemented using a long position in an inflation-linked bond and a short position in the government bond futures contract for each country. We are using futures rather than a short position in a cash government bond for the sake of simplicity, both for implementing the trade and measuring returns. The new trades will be implemented on a duration-matched basis. This means only selling enough of the 10-year bond futures to hedge against any directional move in the yield of the long 10-year inflation-linked bond. A straight comparison of the duration of linkers to futures cannot be made, since inflation-linked bonds have a duration to real yields while futures (and cash government bonds) have a duration to nominal yields. The durations for inflation-linked bonds are always higher than those of nominals (Chart 10), thus the index-linked durations must be adjusted by the beta of changes in real yields to changes in nominal bond yields. To determine the correct duration adjustment, we use betas taken from rolling three-year regressions of monthly changes of 10-year inflation-linked yields on changes in 10-year nominal government yields, using generic Bloomberg tickers. The common convention is to simply apply a yield beta of 0.5 for all inflation-linked bonds (this is the default setting on Bloomberg valuation tools). We think having a variable yield beta is a more accurate way to hedge out the directional risk in each trade from shifts in real bond yields. Chart 11Yield Betas For Inflation-Linked Bonds Vary Across Countries The current yield betas for all eight countries where we have inflation breakeven fair value models are shown in Chart 11 – it is clear from the chart that using a constant yield beta of 0.5 across countries is not accurate, as they vary widely across countries. Multiplying the duration of the actual inflation-linked bond used in our breakeven trades by our rolling yield beta creates a “nominal” duration measure that can then be compared to the duration on the short leg of the breakeven trade. For futures, we use the empirical duration estimates from Bloomberg using the “FRSK” function. The ratio of the beta-adjusted linker duration to the empirical duration of the bond futures creates the hedge ratio that we will use when measuring the returns of this now “risk-matched” breakeven trade. The actual bonds, futures contracts and hedge ratios for all of our new breakeven trades can all be found in the table on page 18, with initial entry prices for all securities. We will begin to monitor the trade returns in next week’s report. Bottom Line: We are reviving our Tactical Trade Overlay with inflation-linked bond breakeven trades in the US, Italy and Canada. Appendix: 10-Year Inflation Break Even Model Chart 12Our US 10-Year Inflation Breakeven Model Chart 13Our UK 10-Year Inflation Breakeven Model Chart 14Our France 10-Year Inflation Breakeven Model Chart 15Our Italy 10-Year Inflation Breakeven Model Chart 16Our Japan 10-Year Inflation Breakeven Model Chart 17Our Germany 10-Year Inflation Breakeven Model Chart 18Our Canada 10-Year Inflation Breakeven Model Chart 19Our Australia 10-Year Inflation Breakeven Model Robert Robis, CFA Chief Fixed Income Strategist rrobis@bcaresearch.com Footnotes 1 Please see BCA Research Global Fixed Income Strategy Weekly Report, "Global Inflation Expectations Are Too Low", dated April 28, 2020, available at gfis.bcaresearch.com. 2 Please see BCA Research Commodity & Energy Strategy Weekly Report, "Low Vol, High Uncertainty Keeps Oil-Price Rally On Tenterhooks", dated June 18, 2020, available at ces.bcaresearch.com. Recommendations The GFIS Recommended Portfolio Vs. The Custom Benchmark Index Duration Regional Allocation Spread Product Tactical Trades Yields & Returns Global Bond Yields Historical Returns
The copper/gold ratio troughed at the end of March and has been rising ever since. When the price of copper leads the price of gold higher, the market is sniffing out the positive impact on growth of reflation efforts by global central banks and fiscal…
The pound historically is a pro-cyclical currency. The UK sports a current account deficit of 3.74% of GDP. Funding such a large deficit is easier when global liquidity is plentiful, when global growth is strong, and when risk aversion is decreasing. The…
The May Chicago Fed National Activity Index suggests a V-shape recovery is taking hold of the US. The National Activity Index surged from -17.89 to an all-time high of 2.61. A reading above zero is consistent with above-trend growth in the US, and in May, the…

